with Mushroom Sauce

  Great family restaurant every time you walk in your treated with respect and courtesy. I'm a New Yorker so I know a lil bit about quality pizza and Italian food. Everything I get here I always enjoy. Only a few blocks from the house my new spot .. thank you for the great service and delicious foods .

marcus garcia
4/04/2019

  Delicious pizza. Both Sicilian and New York style. Great sauce 👍

Tammy Shatto
5/14/2019

  Great food, friendly service. Best pizza restaurant in Mechanicsburg by far.

Borneo Jimmy
11/16/2018

  Love this place have been going there for 20 years! Still great food!

Zachary Murtorff
12/07/2018

  We had the Sicilian Lunch combo...Delish!

Crystal
11/01/2018

  Good food for a good price. Very clean establishment. Very friendly staff. They even gave my daughters some candy on the way out. I’ll definitely come back.

James Butterfield
5/10/2019

  I would rate this Pizza place 6 stars. Sal's Pizza is the real deal . Fresh subs and steak sandwiches stuffed with meat and some of the very best pizza in the area. Wings cooked to perfection, nice and CRISPY and great tasting sauces. Pizza made the way it's supposed to be, nice thin dough perfect amount of sauce and toppings. The owners are nice people to talk to and care about putting out a great product for their customers. My whole family agrees that they have the best pizza and we usually like different things but all agree on Sal's . Can't go wrong eating here. We highly recommend Sal's Pizza !!!

Rich W
1/03/2019

  Beautifully remodeled dining areas. Yummy pizza. Very pleasant staff.

Brenda Maun
10/04/2018

  The family's been going here for just over a decade now and it won't be ending anytime soon. IMO this place is honestly the same taste wise with the nearby JoJo's. Just that this place is a little bit cheaper and their red mushrooms taste waaaaay better. If you go here I would recommend the chicken alfredo as they offer a variety of noodles to choose from and their proportions are quite large compared to other places.

Jacky Phan
9/18/2018

  Had the Italian sub... huge but left something to be desired, meat spread too thin, bread a little soft. Pizza looked good tho.

Tyler Cloetingh
5/24/2019

  The food here is really good. I don't like all the tvs and noise going on, but it is a comfortable place to sit and eat. I like how they renovated it.

Susanne Zeiders
6/19/2019

  Best pizza and food around beautiful remodel of shop

Adam Bankert
11/12/2018

  Our lunch orders came out very fast and were delicious!

Erin Moul
1/05/2019

  Really good and quick with friendly staff

Daniel Suter
12/11/2018

  Great food. Good service.

Larry Fisher
12/28/2018

  I thought the Sicilian pizza was excellent. The crust was perfect, and so was the sauce

Moonshadow Moonshadow
3/14/2019

  Been traveling for work and when I'm in the area I try a new place each time. Sal's was my next pick. To start.. Very friendly staff. The person that answered the phone didn't get annoyed with all my questions. He was very helpful. I ordered a large pizza and a dozen of wings. Let's start with the good. The pizza.. generous amount of topping. Crust was good and loved the sauce on the pizza. Nice big slices. Now the not so good. The wings.. Cheap price for a dozen wings. Nice and meaty buttttt the flavor was just not enough. I had honey mustard and I just wanted more sauce! With that being said I still gave 5 stars.. This is an Italian PIZZA place.. Can't hold that against them, and with the pizza being great and the staff being friendly was enough for me. Thanks guys! Just remember.. Keep calm and eat Sal's pizza!

Jerad Kolbosky
2/22/2019

  Always great food and service.

Milo Stavely
2/02/2019

  Always great customer service and the pizza sauce full of flavor. We love it.

Denise Nace
3/06/2019

  I love the subs here they are awesome. The wings aren't the absolute best in town but they have about the best deal on big wing orders and the guys that run the place are so nice I sometimes go out of my way just to give them my business. I'd recommend Sal's to everybody

Donald Draper
6/08/2019

  Boy was that good! And fast! Large Pepperoni Take Out was ready when they said it would be.

Fred Thumma
2/20/2019

  Pizza and subs are great. Pasta dinners are very good. Better than JoJos, hands down.

Dogefan19967
7/08/2019

  Excellent as always. Best sauce around.

J.L. Bruner
2/20/2019

  The food is always fresh and the owners are always pleasant! Wonderful place with authentic tasting food.

Sherry Chubb
6/28/2019

  Good food and atmosphere! Friendly staff. I had a veggie stromboli and it was tasty and big enough to take home. I recommend Sal's if you want yummy pizza! Great experience. Thank you!

Nicole Willshier
2/03/2019

  One of the best in Mechanicsburg. I have been eating the cheeseburger sub lunch combo with a raspberry iced tea since 1999. Of course the price went up but the food is the same. We have ordered thousands of subs and pizzas from them. It has a tiny parking lot out front that is tough to get into. They do have additional parking behind the building. But on nice days i park in the baseball field parking lot across the street. Family owned and run.

Dusty Agerton
1/16/2019

  One of the best! We will be back. Great pizza and friendly and courteous service.

Lisa Haines
5/10/2019

  Mushroom cheesesteak is phenomenal. Definitely coming back. The dining room and bathrooms are clean and tidy. Friendly staff.

Erin Napoli
3/21/2019